Friday, August 2, 2013

A lesson on How to cheat people and mislead voters

People’s expectations belied

RISHIKESH BAHADUR DESAI
SHARE  ·   PRINT   ·   T+  

Article 371-J limits reservation to a specific region only

M. Veerappa Moily, Petroleum Minister, had announced that the amendment to Article 371-J of the Constitution to grant special status to Hyderabad-Karnataka was better than similar provisions in Andhra Pradesh and Maharashtra. However, a close reading of the amendment reveals that the provision seems to fall below people’s expectations.
The most important limitation is in extending regional reservation to the residents of the six north-eastern districts. While the amendment for Andhra Pradesh, Article 371-D, extends benefits of reservation to Telangana residents in educational institutions across that State, the provisions for Karnataka restrict such facilities only to Hyderabad-Karnataka region.
The amendment (Article 371-D) empowers the Andhra Pradesh government to take steps to ensure reservation to Telangana residents “for the purposes of admission to any university within the State or to any other educational institution which is subject to the control of the State government (Section 3-B-III).
However, Article 371-J clearly limits such benefits to be made available in educational institutions within Hyderabad Karnataka.
Similarly disappointing is the provision for employment. While Article 371-D has a blanket provision of reservation “for direct recruitment to posts in any cadre under any local authority within the State or any local cadre under the State government’’ (Section 3-B-II), Article 371-J restricts the reservation to Gulbarga revenue division that includes the Hyderabad-Karnataka districts.
Hyderabad Karnataka Horata Samiti and other civil society groups have criticised this. “Did we fight for 25 long years for this?” asks Anil Kumar Beldar, divisional general secretary of the samiti. “Our boys and girls are getting admissions and jobs in this region. What is the purpose of giving reservation to us in our own area?” he wondered.
“We have registered our protest in a letter to Chief Minister Siddaramaiah. We have sought rules that would provide our students 25 per cent reservation in admission in educational institutions and public employment across Karnataka. If such rules are not possible under the existing amendment, the Constitution needs to be further amended. If that does not happen, we will intensify our agitation,” Mr. Beldar said.
B.G. Shetkar, president of Bidar Chamber of Commerce, said that he too was not happy with the provision.
“What is the point in having the amendment if students from Bidar and Gulbarga don’t get reservation in medical and engineering colleges in Bangalore and Mysore?” Mr. Shetkar said.
As much as 21 per cent of Karnataka’s population resides in Hyderabad-Karnataka region. So, the reservation should be 21 per cent. But more important is that this facility should be available at the State level. “In fact, we have urged the H.K. Patil committee to draft rules to give 21 per cent reservation in education and employment at the State level and 79 per cent in the Hyderabad-Karnataka region. If this does not happen, then we will approach the Union government again,” he said.

  • Earlier, the amendment was said to be better than similar provisions in Andhra Pradesh, Maharashtra
  • ‘It should benefit students from the region seeking education, jobs in the entire State’


  • Saga of Check Dams in Bidar

    ‘The positive effect of these structures is obvious’

    RISHIKESH BAHADUR DESAI
    SHARE  ·   PRINT   ·   T+  

    The 1,300 check dams constructed in the district have helped in replenishing Bidar’s water reserves

    The single arch buttress check dam in Chitta village in Bidar taluk.— Photo: Gopichand T.
    The single arch buttress check dam in Chitta village in Bidar taluk.— Photo: Gopichand T.
    In 2003, the district administration spent Rs. 85 lakh a year to supply drinking water in tankers to 70 villages in the district. Nine years on, the tankers have completely vanished.
    This is mainly owing to the 1,300 check dams and feeder watersheds in the district, which have greatly helped in replenishing the district’s water reserves over the last few years. Impact studies conducted by the Mines and Geology Department revealed that “there was very high sustainability of ground water” over two four-year cycles due to these check dams.
    “The positive effect of these structures is obvious,” said P.M. Khan, senior geologist who authored the impact report. “Most of the sugarcane in the district is on non-irrigated land. Despite that, farmers have produced enough sugarcane for three factories and ten Khandsari (mini-sugar making units). Across the five taluks, villages ranging from Karpakapall in Humnabad, which has the highest rainfall, to Kamal Nagar in Aurad, which receives the least, these structures have made a difference to the lives of people,” he said.
    He points out that the check dams have helped recharge wells and increased the yield of borewells. A single check dam built on a stream in Chitta village has not only ended the village’s water scarcity but also helped villages downstream, such as Amalapur, Gornalli and others. The single or multiple arch buttress check dams, developed by the Bidar Zilla Panchayat, have now acquired the moniker ‘Bidar-model’ check dams. They are four times cheaper than traditional stone check dams and last ten times longer. They are easier to build, as prefabricated components can be used to erect them. The arch in the middle redistributes the water throughout the structure, making impounding of water easier than other watershed structures. Check dams have also proved to be cost-effective.
    On average, a major irrigation project impounds between 89 and 102 litres of water for every rupee spent. The check dams, however, have succeeded in holding back 150 litres of water for every rupee spent, according to zilla panchayat engineer Arun Kumar.
    Impressed by their performance, Chief Secretary S.V. Ranganath recommended that such structures be constructed across the State, especially in areas where the groundwater level has fallen. “Check dams have also been built in some villages of Hassan district where all the water sources were fluoride-contaminated. Their impact is being studied,” said Naveen Raj Singh, Commissioner, Social Welfare.
    A team led by Mr. Singh and IFS officer Manoj Kumar had designed the new check dams and built the first 300 structures. Then, Bidar Zilla Panchayat engineers Mallikarjun Gunge, N.A Patil and Arun Kumar and others continued to construct the ‘Bidar-model’ check dams under various schemes.
    “These check dams are the pride of Bidar. The district has 600 villages and 300 hamlets. It means we have three check dams for every two villages. Farmers who opposed the construction of check dams near their fields, are now inviting us to build them on their land,” said zilla panchayat president Latha Harkude.

    Why Tipu University should not come up in Sri Rangapattana

    Why not minority varsity in a largely minority area?

      RISHIKESH BAHADUR DESAI
      MOHAMMAD ALI
    SHARE  ·   PRINT   ·   T+  

    Union Ministry wants to set up the university in Srirangapatna

    Should the Union government set up the proposed university for minorities in Srirangapatna, in Mandya district, or in one of the northern Karnataka districts where the population of minorities is high?
    This question is being raised by academicians and leaders from minority-dominated areas in the State, even as Union Minority Affairs Minister K. Rahman Khan has urged the State government to find 200 acres of land in Srirangapatna to set up the university.
    Thorat report
    The debate gains significance as the Sukhdeo Thorat Committee — constituted by the Union Ministry of Minority Affairs to go into various aspects of the five minority universities proposed to be set up by the Centre — had favoured setting up of the Central universities in minority-concentrated areas.
    “We welcome the government’s decision to set up a university for minorities, but it will serve its purpose better if it is in a place with high concentration of minorities,” Khaji Arshed Ali, former MLC and editor of the Urdu daily Surkh Zameen , said. “What is the point of establishing a university there if it does not have the targeted population nearby?” he said.
    The entire Mandya district (of which Srirangapatna is a taluk), he argued, had less than 5 per cent Muslims. In contrast, for example, the percentage of Muslims is 20 in the Bidar Assembly constituency and 25 in the Mangalore Assembly constituency.
    Rev. Samuel Ramappa, who retired as the principal of Norma Fendrick College in Bidar, said that Gulbarga and Bidar were counted among the 90 minority-concentrated districts in the country which had a significant number of Muslims, Christians, Buddhists and Jains.
    D.N Akki, Jain scholar and writer, added that placing the university between the two big cities of Bangalore and Mysore lacked logic “Between them, they have more than 10 universities. Why struggle to set up one more institution in an already crowded academic environment?” he said.
    He said the 12th Plan spoke of setting up institutions in areas where students don’t have easy access to higher education.
    Talking to The Hindu , Prof. Thorat reiterated that he had recommended that the universities should be established in “areas predominantly inhabited by minority population so that more and more youth from minority communities can join the higher educational streams.”
    Not relenting
    However, the Union government appears to be in no mood to relent on the issue. Officials in the Ministry of Minority Affairs told The Hindu that the decision to establish Tipu Sultan university at Srirangapatna was taken by Mr. Rahman Khan’s predecessors such as A.R. Antulay and there was “no going back on that.”
    On the specific recommendation of the Thorat committee, they said that to accept and implement the committee’s recommendations was entirely the “discretion” of the Ministry.


  • ‘The varsity will serve its purpose better if it is in a place with high concentration of minorities’
  • ‘Entire Mandya district has less than 5 per cent Muslims’



  • Monday, January 2, 2012

    Urdu literature, journalism and calligraphy


    Date:20/07/2007 URL:

     The prayer for all

     RISHIKESH BAHADUR DESAI

     None would imagine that the piety-filled prayer that emerges from the
     tomb of the Prophet in Madina  has its roots in Bidar. It was written
     by Hazrat Ishqui, a poet from Bidar

     HOARY PAST A file photo of Rajya Sabha member, the late Maqsood Ali
     Khan, felicitating Rashid Ahmed Rashid in Bidar. Rashid was called
     Shayar-e-Hayat by fans


     The air around the Masjid –E-Nabavi in Mecca in Saudi Arabia
     reverberates with the sound of the prayer “Ya Shafi Ul Wara Salam Un
     Alaik…”, five times a day, everyday. This mosque, also called the
     Mosque of Prophet Mohammad, co ntains the tomb of Prophet Mohammad and
     is considered holy by Muslims all over the world.

     The prayer sung here is written in praise of the Prophet. This
     beautiful piece of Arabic poetry is the creation of Hazrat Ishqui, who
     lived in Bidar in Karnataka nearly 200 years ago. The saint poet
     Hazrat Ishqui is revered across the globe. His religious writings in
     Arabic and Farsi are still recited by believers in Iran, Egypt,
     Indonesia and other countries.

     Hazrat Ishqui was born in Bidar. Kings of the Asaf Zahi dynasty
     supported him. He lived in this historic city till he was very old. He
     died in Hyderabad around 1805.

     Bidar has had a glorious literary tradition. Its fame was so
     widespread that modern writer Mohsin Quamal described it in his
     shayari: “Bidar Hai Jiska Naam Voh Ek Shaher –E –Gazal Hai” (Bidar is
     that place which is the city of songs).

     It is said that the lyrical novel “Masnavi Padam Rao Kadam Rao”,
     published in Bidar between 1325–1338 is the first ever publication in
     Urdu. “Research in Karachi University in Pakistan has confirmed this,”
     says Quazi Arshad Ali, editor of the Hindi daily, Bidar Ki Awaaz.

     The first king to patronise arts and literature was Sultan Humanyun of
     the Bahmani Sultanate in the 14th century.

     The Bahmani Kings ruled this province till the late 16th Century.
     Baridshahi kings took over from them. Bidar was the capital for both
     kingdoms. Both these dynasties supported writers. Prominent among
     those who received their patronage are Abdul Quareem Hamdani, Mulla
     Nizami, Syed Taheer, Mulla Dawoodi, Mulla Quashfi, Mahamood and
     Qutbuddin Quadri.

     A very important poet of the period was Feroze Bidri who lived during
     the transition period between Bahmani and Baridshahi kings. He is
     credited to have brought out the first poetry collection in Urdu. His
     collections are preserved in the Kolkota museum. Great poets like
     Mulla Wazhi and Ibne-e-Nishati have called him Ustad Shayar or
     “teacher”, informs literary critic Anees Hashmi. After spending his
     youth in Bidar which was then called Mohammadabad- Bidar, Feroze
     settled in Golconda where he died.

     Urdu was made the official language of the state by the Nizams of
     Hyderabad. “It is the only period in Indian history that Urdu has
     enjoyed the status of an official language,” observes Mr. Ali. The
     Nizam rule ended in 1948. However, literature continued to flourish in
     Bidar in independent India.

     Interestingly, a significant number of non-Muslims also wrote Urdu
     poetry. Works of Hindus like Pandit Yashwantrao Korekal of Manik Nagar
     and Pandit Damodar Pant ‘Zaki’ and Sikhs like Sardar Charan Singh
     Charan of Bidar are popular even today.

     In the last 100 years, the direction of poetry has changed and writers
     focus more on crisis of modern living. Among the modern writers are
     Hazrat Ghulam Mohinuddin Fitrat, Maqdoom Mohinuddin, Hazrat Wafa,
     Sikandar Ali Wajd, Hazrat Kunj-E-Nasheen, Syed Hussein Saifi and
     Hazrat Sajjad Basha Sajjad. The most famous poet in the recent times
     is Rashid Ahmed Rashid. He is called “Shayar-E-Hayat” or the Sun who
     shines on the land of poetry. He went to Osmania University for
     studies and came back to settle in Bidar. In the annals of Urdu
     literary history, he has been compared to Jigar Moradabadi and Josh
     Maliabadi of Uttar Pradesh. He is known as the poet who turned the
     attention of the poetical world away from the themes of love, beauty,
     and the intoxicating effect of love and liqour. He spoke of human
     suffering, enlightenment and philosophy. His first collection,
     Kham-E-Abrao (’The twist of the eye brow’) earned him instant praise
     and recognition. His most famous work is Ilham-O- Yakeen, or
     “Enlightenment”. It is a treatise in philosophy and dwells into
     problems faced by mankind and its possible solutions. He reflected the
     poverty and deprivation of his fellowmen in the poem “Sitam Rashida
     Hoon”.

     His contemporary Suleiman Khatib popularised the Dakhani Urdu or the
     desi dialect. Khatib’s poetry is marked with wit and humour. His
     couplets are known for their multiple layers of meanings. His “Kivde
     Ka Ban” describes a garden of beautiful flowers that may be concealing
     dangerous snakes.

     Other important writers are Ata Kalyanvi who popularised the Naat
     style of poetry and Desi Bukhari of Chitaguppa who used the Dakhani
     Urdu. Allah Baksh Bakshi and Mohammad Jahangeer have also helped put
     the name of Bidar on the map of Urdu poetry.

     Writers like Anees Hashmi, Quaisar Rehman Basit Khan Sofi and others
     are still active and continue to bring out poetry and works of
     criticism.




     Date:07/09/2007 URL:

     100, and not out

     RISHIKESH BAHADUR DESAI

     Bidar has a rich past in journalism. October marks the centenary of
     Urdu journalism in the district

     GOES A LONG WAY A copy of the Bidar Gazette magazine dated January 16, 1909

     This advertisement appeared in the Subhe–Bahar literary magazine in
     Mysore in 1909. “Please read the ‘Urdu Weekly Bidar Gazette’ published
     from Mohammadabad Bidar. Edited by Meher Ali, it is in its third yea r
     of publication and contains news from the Nizam State and speaks about
     national and international issues. It provides complete information on
     topics like education, culture, ethics, religious reform and history.
     The subscription rates are Rs. 12 per annum for zamindars, the rich
     and the advocates, Rs. 6 for the general purchasers and Rs. 3.75 for
     students and the poor.”

     This shows that Bidar had an enviable heritage of journalism. October
     marks the centenary of Urdu journalism in Bidar. In fact, it marks the
     centenary of journalism in Hyderabad-Karnataka region as no attempts
     were made to start a newspaper or magazine in any language at that
     time.

     Historians consider Bidar as the second capital of Urdu journalism in
     the State. “Khasimul Akhbar published in 1862 in Bangalore is the
     first Urdu newspaper of Karnataka. Bidar Gazette, first published on
     October 8, 1907, was the first journalistic venture in any language in
     the Hyderabad Karnataka,” says Anees Siddiqui, researcher and author
     of the book “The History of Urdu Journalism in Karnataka”.

     Bidar Gazette had 12 pages with three columns. Each column had 40
     lines. Each page contained a separate topic. Each page had pointers
     like Provincial, National, International, Culture, Religion and
     Health.

     It used to exchange information and pages from other papers like
     Khadiyan, Niyar, Rehnuma-E-Taleem, Moradabad, and Lahore. The editors
     did not pay for the copies of other papers. They bartered copies of
     their pape rs for other papers. Apart from staff correspondents, the
     magazine invited experts to contribute.

     The earliest available copy of the Bidar Gazette is of January 16,
     1909. It is preserved in the Mohammad Gawan Urdu Arabic library in
     Bidar. Unfortunately, Bidar Gazette stopped after nearly a decade of
     publication.

     Bidar readers had to wait for a long time for the second paper.
     Anti-Nizam activists and revolutionaries started some wall papers in
     1940s. They were imaginatively named as Bala Ghat, Mohammad Gawan,
     Rafi and Jinnah . They were regularly brought out and pasted on the
     same walls each time.

     Insaniyat, the first weekly after independence was started by
     Moinuddin Moinabadi. The magazine was short lived. “We faced a revenue
     crunch,” says Mr. Moinabadi, the last of the surviving senior
     journalists of the district. Other senior Urdu journalists have been
     Mukhtar Ahmed Gilani, Abdul Sattar Adib, Mohsin Kamal, M.A. Hamid,
     Quaisar Rehman and S.I. Quadri. Mr. Gilani was the founder president
     of the Journalists Association in Bidar.

     Abdul Wahid’s Waqt Ka Paigam began as a weekly in 1964. It was turned
     into a daily for sometime before it closed in 1968. Poet and former
     MLC Mohsin Kamal started Gawan, a Urdu daily in 1968. However, it did
     not continue after his death in the 80s.

     Other papers that did not have a long life span were Behmani Samachar
     of Sabagat Ulla, Aftab–e-Bidar of Fadeedullah Alfi, Basat-e -Hayat of
     Shamsul Islam. M.A. Hamid started the English we ekly Hyderabad
     Karnataka from Gulbarga in 1960. He later converted it into a Urdu
     daily and began publishing from Bidar in 1979. It is still running
     successfully. S.I. Quadri’s Adabbi Akkas started in 1984 is s till in
     publication. His son S. S. Quadri edits it now.

     MLC Quazi Arshad Ali started the Surkh Zameen daily in 1993. It is an
     uninterrupted publication since then. It is well read both in the city
     and outside.

     Even non-Muslims have been active in Urdu journalism. R. Ganapath Rao
     started Rafiq, a Urdu newspaper soon after independence. “Bidar has
     the largest number of Urdu schools in the State. It means the district
     produces so many people who can read and write Urdu every year. The
     readership of Urdu newspapers is also growing year on year,” says Mr.
     Arshad Ali.

     The Hindu,
     Friday Review
     Friday, Aug 17, 2007

     The flower-like letter

     Imagine a style of writing being compared to the glistening hair of
     the bride. Such evocative images can emerge only from the grand art of
     calligraphy. Sadly, it is withering away for lack of patronage
     RISHIKESH BAHADUR DESAI

     FADING CITADEL Mohammad Quaza demonstrates his art. With no takers
     left, he leads his life painting posters
     “Let me enjoy the aroma of flowers around here,” says the epitaph of
     Sultan Mehmood Shah Bahmani the third, who once ruled Bidar. The
     Arabic and Farsi letters are arranged in such an artistic manner on
     the tomb stone, that they look like flowers in blossom.

     Islamic Calligraphy, called Fun –E- Khattat is present on almost all
     the historic buildings in Bidar. It adds to the beauty of these 100 or
     so tombs, Masjids and Dargahs in and around the historic city.

     Calligraphy is also defined as the art of giving form to signs.
     Islamic calligraphy is said to have evolved nearly 100 years after the
     death of the Prophet Mohammad. The Islamic belief that only the
     Almighty can create beauteous forms, led some artistes to create
     beautiful forms using letters, says Anees Hashmi, Islamic scholar and
     calligrapher.

     The pioneer of calligraphy is believed to be the fourth Calipha Hazrat
     Ali who used various handwriting styles to document the verses of the
     Quran and sayings of the Prophet Mohammad. The Quran is in Arabic
     script and the art of calligraphy spread wherever Arabic began to be
     used as an influence of Islam.

     The various styles of calligraphy are Khat-e-Qufi, popular in Iraq,
     Khat-e-Sulas that is popular in Iran and India, and Khat-e-Nasq, and
     Khat-e-Nastaliq, used by many Urdu newspapers today. Most of the
     structures in Bidar are in the Sulas style, indicating its century old
     connections with Iran.



     Various forms of calligraphy developed over the years. They are Gulzar
     or the garden, Tawoos or the peacock, Zulf-e-Aroos, or the bride’s
     hair, Manshoor or the triangle, Badr-e-Kamal or the crescent moon,
     Vilayat or the exotic, Ummul Khubus or the Gestalt style, Mahi or the
     fish, Nakhoon or nails, Gauhar or pearls, and Toghra, that uses
     letters to produce various forms of landscapes and designs.

     Calligraphy was an essential part of the education of Kings. Babar,
     Humayun, Akbar and Jehangir were all great calligraphers, says
     Mohammad Quaza, one of the senior calligraphers in Bidar.

     The reign of Qutb-Ud-Din-Aibak is known as the golden era of
     calligraphy. Aurangazeb Alamgir was a great calligrapher and used
     liquid gold to make copies of the Quran. He used money thus earned on
     his personal expenses. Some such copies of the Holy Book are preserved
     in many museums across the country.

     There were many women calligraphers like Shehzadi Gulbadan Begum,
     Jahan Ara Begum and Zebunnisa Begum. It is saidHumayun weighed
     Shehzadi Begum in pearls after she wrote a verse from the Quran on a
     poppy seed. There have been Hindus who excelled in calligraphy. Suraj
     Bhan and Chandra Bhan of Delhi were great Arabic calligraphers during
     Shah Jahan’s time.

     Poet Mohammad Iqbal translated Bhratahari’s Neeti Shataka into Urdu
     and wrote it using calligraphy. Many of Dr. Iqbal’s poems written in
     calligraphic styles are used as wall hangings in many homes, explains
     Mr. Hashmi.

     In Bidar, the fort, the Mohammad Gawan Madrassa, the tomb of Ahmed
     Shah Wali in Ashtur, the tomb of Qualilullah Kirmani in Choukhandi,
     tomb of Abul Faiz, the tombs of Barid Shahi Kings Ali Barid and Quasim
     Barid, and others have beautiful pieces of calligraphy on the walls
     and ceiling. Iranian artist Mughees Shiraz is said to have carried out
     the carvings inside the Bidar fort. “Bidar has a great heritage of
     calligraphy. At one time, being a Urdu journalist meant being a
     calligrapher. The situation has changed only after computers began to
     be used in newspaper offices,” says Quazi Alioddin, a senior
     journalist with the Hindi daily, Bidar Ki Awaaz.

     There are many calligraphers in Bidar now. However, not all of them
     are leading a comfortable life. Senior calligrapher Mohammad Quaza was
     trained in the Nastaliq style in Arabic and Urdu. He is also equally
     skilled in English, Hindi and Kannada calligraphy. Sadly, he now lives
     his life painting film posters.

     Retired teacher Abdul Raheem, mastered the art of writing mirror
     images of Arabic and Urdu letters, as it was necessary for screen
     printing. Asifa Rahi still paints portraits and writes film posters.
     He also paints signboards.

     Mohammad Zafar Ulla Khan produced handwritten books. This is how
     Bidar’s famed poet Rashid Ahmed Rashid’s books were first published.
     Moin Yaar Khan who was a great hockey player, developed fast writing
     method in calligraphy. Former MLC Mohsin Kamal brought out Gawan, a
     calligraphic daily newspaper.

     Abdul Wahab and Ameen Ud Din Nawaaz are credited with reviving the art
     in Bidar. Mr. Nawaaz is keeping the tradition alive by teaching
     students calligraphy. Over 100 students attend his lessons. “This
     shows that the art is not dead,” he says.

     Mr. Wahab who retired as a teacher, is considered a calligrapher of
     international standards. He visits the nearly 90 mosques in the
     district at least once every month. He writes verses from the Quran
     and other holy scriptures along with their meanings on the black
     boards there. His visits are so popular that people look forward to
     them. In many Masjids, the practice of keeping black boards started
     after he began writing.

     Other calligraphers like Qaisar Rehman, Anees Hashmi, Syed Quadri,
     Javed Mohammad, Akbar Ali, Abdul Sattar Adib and Gaffar Jaffar, Sheikh
     Ismail, Mohsin Kamal, Quaisar Rehman, Anees Hashmi have brought
     laurels to Bidar with their artistic writing.

     End